Campbell Core Technology: Datalogger Analog Measurement Uncertainty

by Kevin Rhodes | Updated: 05/17/2018 | Comments: 0

Search the Blog


Subscribe to the Blog

Get an email when a new article is posted. Choose the topics that interest you most.


Area / Application

Product Category

Activity

Corporate / News

Enter your email address:



Suggest an Article

Is there a topic you would like to learn more about? Let us know.

Leave this field empty

bell curve for measurement uncertainty

Do you ever wonder about the uncertainty of your measurements? Occasionally, I’ll have a researcher ask how he or she can calculate the analog measurement uncertainty of a datalogger. I usually direct the customer to the specification sheet that we publish. The customer then asks which statistical method we used to come up with the published accuracy. For example, did we use the Monte Carlo method, the three-sigma method, etc.?  At first, I didn’t understand the question. (I guess that is what I get for choosing other elective courses and avoiding college statistics classes.) It took me a while to understand what the customer was asking, and I’ll explain why. 

As a customer, you don’t have to wonder if your Campbell Scientific datalogger falls outside the third standard deviation of our specifications. We guarantee that our dataloggers will operate within our published specifications over our published temperature range. We tested them—every one—and they passed. While we do rely on statistical analysis to set accuracy expectations during the design phase of new dataloggers, that plays no part in verifying the actual production performance of your datalogger.

So, the question really being asked is this: how much does the datalogger contribute to the measurement uncertainty? To calculate this, you should know that we use a "worst-case" method for creating our specifications and an "as-tested" method for each datalogger. The "as-tested" information is found on the datalogger calibration certificate available on your Campbell Scientific customer account, listed by datalogger model and serial number.

  1. To access this information, ensure you are logged in to our website, and navigate to the Your Account page. (For assistance, watch the "Certificates of Calibration" video.)
  2. Click Calibration Certificates in the Account Menu:
    Account Menu on Your Account page
  3. Select the product from the drop-down menu, enter your product’s serial number, and click Search:
    Calibration Certificates section
  4. Click Download to access your calibration certificate.

After reviewing your calibration certificate, you may be thinking that's all fine and good for when you first get your datalogger and it’s brand new. But will your datalogger remain in calibration over time? 

In 2013, we decided to look at the analog measurement drift of our CR1000 datalogger to see if we could determine how often a customer should send in a datalogger for recalibration. We hired a statistician to go through all our "as shipped" and "as returned" data. From this data, I discovered that, even though we were recommending a three-year calibration interval, we didn’t get many dataloggers returned to us for calibration.

You might think that of the 100,000 CR1000 dataloggers we’ve sold, we would have a huge calibration data set. Well, we don’t. At the time of the analysis, we had sold 55,823 CR1000 dataloggers, and only 434 of those had been returned for calibration. This is equal to a sample population that is 0.78% of the total population. Despite the relatively small fraction of dataloggers returned for calibration, the statistician assured me that 434 paired data sets were more than enough to produce meaningful results. The study calculated the drift between "as shipped" and "as returned" for ten voltage measurements on each datalogger. The voltage measurements included a combination of single ended and differential, positive and negative, across six voltage ranges from channel one.

The analysis determined that there was no correlation between the age of the datalogger and drift in the analog measurements. It didn’t matter how long you had a CR1000 datalogger because the analog measurements didn’t drift out of spec.

Since the 2013 study, we have continued to look for measurement drift as dataloggers are returned for recalibration. The good news is that there continues to be a lack of correlation between the age of the datalogger and drift in the analog measurements.

So, how do we get our dataloggers to stay within the specifications?

  • We design our dataloggers with parts that have extremely low temperature drift.
  • We calibrate each datalogger over temperature.
  • We have our own extremely stable voltage reference built into the datalogger.
  • We check this reference with every measurement or every few minutes, depending on the settings.

Yes, we check every measurement against a reference. Our Engineering Department calls this the "belt-and-suspenders" method (not in statistics books), which means that we use multiple procedures to achieve this constant adherence to specifications.

So, after reading all this, you may wonder why we still recommend calibration of our dataloggers every three years. When measurements matter, it’s good to have both before-and-after calibration information for comparison. And, thanks in advance for helping us increase our sample population!

If you have a question or comment related to the analog accuracy of our dataloggers, calibration, or drift, please post it below.


Share This Article



About the Author

kevin rhodes Kevin Rhodes is the Director of Core Technologies at Campbell Scientific, Inc., where he has been employed for more than 20 years. He has been instrumental in setting the specifications for several of our dataloggers. Kevin has a bachelor's degree in electrical engineering from Utah State University. He contributes to our environmental sustainability efforts by frequently bicycling to and from work, which is of noteworthy distance.

View all articles by this author.


Comments

Please log in or register to comment.